Question 1

How are HOA covenants enforced in Florida?

Accepted Answer

HOA covenant enforcement under Chapter 720: the association's board is responsible for enforcing the governing documents (declaration of covenants, bylaws, and rules). Enforcement methods: written violation notices (identifying the specific covenant violated and the required corrective action), fines (up to $100 per violation per day, not to exceed $1,000 in aggregate per violation, imposed by the fining committee under §720.305), suspension of use rights (suspension of the right to use common areas for up to 90 days), legal action (the association can file a lawsuit to obtain injunctive relief or damages), and lien and foreclosure (for unpaid assessments, not for covenant violations alone).

Question 2

What protections do homeowners have against HOA enforcement?

Accepted Answer

Homeowner protections: the right to notice and an opportunity to be heard before fines are imposed (§720.305), the right to attend board meetings and speak on enforcement matters, the right to inspect the association's records (including enforcement records), the right to challenge enforcement actions in court (if the enforcement is arbitrary, discriminatory, or exceeds the board's authority), the right to demand that the board enforce covenants consistently (selective enforcement is a defense), the right to mediate disputes before litigation (§720.311 requires pre-suit mediation for many disputes), and the right to recover attorney fees if the homeowner prevails in an enforcement action.

Question 3

What is selective enforcement and how does it affect HOA covenant enforcement?

Accepted Answer

Selective enforcement occurs when an HOA enforces covenants against some homeowners but not others. In Florida, selective enforcement can be a defense to an enforcement action: if the homeowner can show that the association has not enforced the same covenant against other violators, the court may find that the association has waived its right to enforce the covenant. To avoid selective enforcement claims, the board should: enforce covenants consistently against all violators, document all enforcement actions, conduct regular property inspections, and avoid personal favoritism or discrimination in enforcement decisions.

Homeowners Association Covenant Enforcement

HOA Covenant Enforcement in Florida

Enforcement Methods

Homeowner Protections

Selective Enforcement

Related Terms

Barnes Walker HOA Law

Ready to Get Started?