Question 1

How does a keyman clause function in a Florida commercial lease?

Accepted Answer

In a commercial lease, the keyman clause gives the landlord (or sometimes the tenant) specific rights if a named individual is no longer associated with the tenant’s business. Common triggers: the named individual dies, becomes disabled, retires, resigns, or is terminated. Landlord rights upon trigger: the right to terminate the lease (giving the landlord the ability to re-lease to a more stable tenant), the right to require a new personal guaranty from a creditworthy replacement, the right to increase the security deposit, or the right to renegotiate lease terms. Tenant protections: the clause should provide a cure period (time to find a replacement), define what constitutes an "acceptable" replacement, and specify whether the triggering event must be permanent.

Question 2

Why do Florida commercial landlords include keyman clauses?

Accepted Answer

Landlord motivations: the lease was approved based on the specific individual’s creditworthiness, experience, or business track record. If that person leaves, the landlord’s underwriting assumptions may no longer be valid. Common scenarios: a restaurant lease where the chef-owner is the key draw (their departure may cause the restaurant to fail), a professional practice lease where the named practitioner is the revenue generator, a startup tenant where the founder’s vision and relationships drive the business, and a tenant that received favorable lease terms because of the keyman’s personal guaranty. Without a keyman clause, the landlord is bound to the lease even if the person whose involvement justified the favorable terms is no longer involved.

Question 3

How should a Florida tenant negotiate a keyman clause in a commercial lease?

Accepted Answer

Tenant negotiation strategies: limit the triggering events (only death and permanent disability, not voluntary departure or reassignment), require a reasonable cure period (90-180 days to find a replacement), define "acceptable replacement" objectively (specific financial criteria, experience requirements), limit the landlord’s remedies (renegotiation rather than termination), require the landlord to act in good faith when evaluating replacement candidates, include a buyout option (the tenant can pay a termination fee instead of being terminated), and ensure the clause does not apply if the tenant is current on rent and in good standing. The goal is to balance the landlord’s legitimate concern about the key person’s departure with the tenant’s need for lease stability.

Keyman Clause: Commercial Lease

Keyman Clauses in Florida Commercial Leases

How It Works

Why Landlords Use Them

Tenant Negotiation Strategies

Related Terms

Barnes Walker Commercial Leasing

Ready to Get Started?