Question 1

What are the elements of a prescriptive easement in Florida?

Accepted Answer

Florida elements: actual use (the claimant physically used the property for the claimed purpose), open and notorious (the use was visible and apparent to the property owner; not hidden or secretive), continuous and uninterrupted (the use was regular and consistent for the entire 20-year period; seasonal use may qualify if consistent with the nature of the use), adverse and under claim of right (the use was without the owner’s permission and the claimant acted as if they had the right to use the property), and for 20 years (Section 95.12: the use must continue for at least 20 consecutive years).

Question 2

What is the burden of proof for a Florida prescriptive easement?

Accepted Answer

Burden: the claimant must prove each element by clear and convincing evidence (a higher standard than preponderance of the evidence used in most civil cases). This higher standard is required because: a prescriptive easement takes property rights without compensation, the claim is essentially an involuntary transfer of property rights, and Florida courts are cautious about recognizing prescriptive rights. The claimant should: gather extensive evidence (testimony, photographs, surveys, and documents), establish a timeline of use, and demonstrate that the use was truly adverse (not permissive).

Question 3

How do Florida courts treat prescriptive easements over public land?

Accepted Answer

Public land: Florida courts generally do not recognize prescriptive easements over public land. The government: is presumed to have consented to the use (government-owned land is typically open to the public), cannot be subject to adverse claims (government property is held in trust for the public), and is protected by sovereign immunity (the government cannot lose property rights through prescription). Exception: some courts have recognized customary public use of beach areas (the public’s longstanding, customary use of dry sand areas above the mean high-water line).

Prescriptive Easement: in Florida

Prescriptive Easements in Florida

Elements

Burden of Proof

Public Land

Related Terms

Barnes Walker Real Estate

Ready to Get Started?