Question 1

How does undue influence apply to Florida estate contests?

Accepted Answer

FL estate contests: undue influence is one of the most common grounds for contesting a will or trust in FL. Section 732.5165: a will or any part of a will is void if: the will was procured by undue influence. The contestant: must prove that the beneficiary: had a confidential relationship with the decedent, was active in procuring the will (involved in: selecting the attorney, providing instructions, or being present at the execution), and received a substantial benefit under the will (the will disproportionately favors the alleged influencer). If proven: the will (or the tainted provisions) are void and the estate passes under a prior valid will or intestacy.

Question 2

What is the burden of proof for undue influence in Florida estate contests?

Accepted Answer

Burden: the contestant initially bears the burden of establishing a presumption of undue influence by proving: a confidential relationship between the beneficiary and the decedent, active procurement by the beneficiary (the beneficiary was involved in: selecting the attorney, being present at the execution, or providing instructions), and a substantial benefit to the beneficiary. Once the presumption is established: the burden shifts to the beneficiary to prove that the will was not the product of undue influence (they must show: the decedent acted freely and voluntarily, the decedent had independent advice, and the decedent understood the will and its consequences). The standard: preponderance of the evidence.

Question 3

What evidence supports undue influence claims in Florida?

Accepted Answer

Evidence: isolation (the influencer isolated the decedent from family and friends), dependency (the decedent was physically, emotionally, or financially dependent on the influencer), vulnerability (the decedent was elderly, ill, or had diminished capacity), change in estate plan (the decedent changed their will or trust to benefit the influencer shortly before death), involvement in execution (the influencer was present at the signing, selected the attorney, or provided instructions), and unusual provisions (the will disproportionately benefits the influencer at the expense of natural beneficiaries: children or spouse). Expert testimony: from gerontologists, psychologists, and handwriting experts.

Undue Influence in Estate Contest

Undue Influence in Florida Estate Contests

Elements

Burden Shifting

Evidence

Related Terms

Barnes Walker Estate Planning

Ready to Get Started?