
First, take a deep breath. The life you knew is over, and an incredible new one is just beginning. You are holding a ticket worth millions—and you are also facing your first, and most critical, multimillion-dollar business decision.
It’s the question every winner has to answer: Do you take the lump sum or the annuity?
This choice isn’t just about personal preference; it’s a massive legal and financial decision that will impact your taxes, your family, your estate, and your security for the rest of your life.
And in Florida, you are on a tight, irreversible deadline.
The 60-Day “Point of No Return”
This is the most important rule you need to know:
You have exactly 60 days from the winning draw date to elect the one-time, lump-sum “cash option.”
If you fail to actively choose the lump sum within that 60-day window, the Florida Lottery will automatically default you into the annuity. You cannot change your mind.
This 60-day period is your non-negotiable window to assemble your legal and financial team and make a fully informed decision.
Understanding the Two Options
Let’s break down exactly what you’re choosing between. Let’s use a hypothetical $100 Million Jackpot as an example.
- The Annuity: This is the full $100 million prize. You don’t get it all at once. Instead, you get 30 annual payments over 29 years (one immediate payment, 29 more). These payments are graduated, meaning they start smaller and increase by about 5% each year to account for inflation.
- The Lump Sum (Cash Option): This is the “cash value” of the jackpot, which is the amount of money the lottery would need today to fund the annuity payments for 30 years. It is always a smaller number than the advertised jackpot. For our $100 million prize, the lump sum might be around $52 million (the exact amount varies with each jackpot).
Your choice isn’t “Do I want $100 million or $52 million?” The real choice is “Do I want $100 million paid over 30 years, or $52 million right now?”
Here are the legal and financial considerations for each.
The Case for the Lump Sum: Total Control
Taking the cash option is the choice for those who want total control. You get all your money at once (after taxes), and it is yours to manage, invest, and protect.
The Legal & Financial Advantages:
- Estate Planning & Gifting: This is the biggest legal advantage. It is far simpler to plan your estate with a single pot of money. You can immediately fund trusts for your children, create charitable foundations, and make legal gifts to family, all in one clean legal process.
- Asset Protection: A skilled attorney can help you immediately move your winnings into a protected legal structure, such as a family limited partnership or a series of trusts. This can help shield your assets from future creditors, lawsuits, or divorces.
- Investment Control: Your financial team can invest the entire sum in a diversified portfolio that (you hope) will grow at a rate that beats the annuity’s guaranteed return. You have the flexibility to pursue any investment you wish.
The Legal & Financial Risks:
- The Massive Tax Bite: This is the big one. You will pay all of your federal income tax in a single year. That $52 million lump sum will instantly put you in the highest federal tax bracket (currently 37%). The IRS first takes a 24% withholding, but you will owe the remaining 13% (or more) come tax time. That $52 million becomes roughly $32.7 million in an instant. (The good news: Florida has no state income tax on lottery winnings!)
- The Risk of “Sudden Wealth Syndrome”: This is a real, documented risk. You have one chance to manage this money. Bad investments, overspending, and pressure from “friends” and family can (and often does) lead to bankruptcy. The lump sum offers zero protection from your own worst impulses.
The Case for the Annuity: Built-in Security
Taking the annuity is like giving yourself a guaranteed, multimillion-dollar salary for the next 30 years. It is the choice for those who value security and long-term stability.
The Legal & Financial Advantages:
- “Stupid-Proof” Your Winnings: This is the annuity’s greatest feature. You cannot blow all your money in one weekend. If you make a terrible financial mistake one year, you get a fresh, multimillion-dollar check the next year. It is the ultimate protection against overspending.
- A “Lower” Tax Bill (Spread Over Time): You only pay taxes on the income you receive each year. While each payment will almost certainly still put you in the top 37% tax bracket, you are paying that tax on a $3.3 million payment (our $100M/30-year average), not a $52 million payment. This can feel much more manageable.
- Creditor & Lawsuit Protection: In Florida, annuities have strong asset protection qualities. In many cases, a creditor cannot seize your future lottery payments. This makes you a less attractive target for frivolous lawsuits.
The Legal & Financial Risks:
- Zero Flexibility: You cannot call the Florida Lottery and ask for an advance. You cannot access your future payments, period. If a once-in-a-lifetime business or real estate opportunity comes up, you can only use the funds you have on hand.
- Complex Estate Planning: What happens if you die 10 years into your 30-year annuity? This is a critical legal question.
- The good news: The annuity is inheritable. The remaining 20 payments will go to your designated beneficiary or your estate.
- The bad news: Your estate will owe federal estate tax on the entire remaining value of the annuity in the year of your death. This can create a massive tax bill that your heirs may not have the cash to pay, potentially forcing them to sell the annuity payments at a steep discount. A good estate planning attorney can help plan for this, but it is a significant legal complication.
So, Which One is Right for You?
There is no single “correct” answer. The right choice depends entirely on your discipline, age, health, and goals.
| Factor | Lean Towards Lump Sum | Lean Towards Annuity |
| Discipline | You are highly disciplined and trust yourself (and your team) to manage a massive sum responsibly. | You are worried about overspending, family pressure, or making impulsive decisions. |
| Age & Health | You are older or have health concerns. You want to control your full legacy and estate now. | You are young and have a long life ahead. You can benefit from 30 years of guaranteed income. |
| Control | You want full control over your investments, estate planning, and charitable giving immediately. | You are happy to give up control in exchange for absolute, long-term financial security. |
| Legal Ease | You want to set up complex trusts and asset protection plans one time and be done with it. | You prefer to protect your winnings by keeping them out of your own hands. |
The Bottom Line: You cannot make this decision alone. The 60-day clock is ticking.
Your first call is not to your family; it’s to an attorney. A lawyer experienced in wealth management and estate planning will be the “quarterback” who assembles your team (a CPA, a financial advisor) and guides you through the pros and cons for your specific situation.
This is the first test of your new life. Pass it by getting expert legal advice before you do anything else.
Contact Us for a Confidential Consultation
Disclaimer: The information and opinions provided are for general educational, informational or entertainment purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice or a substitute for consultation with a qualified attorney. Any information that you read does not create an attorney–client relationship with Barnes Walker, Goethe, Perron & Shea, PLLC, or any of its attorneys. Because laws, regulations, and court interpretations may change over time, the definitions and explanations provided here may not reflect the most current legal standards. The application of law varies depending on your particular facts and jurisdiction. For advice regarding your specific situation, please contact one of our Florida attorneys for personalized guidance.
Visit our legal department pages:
Real Estate Attorneys
Business Attorneys
Litigation Attorneys
Estate Planning Attorneys
Inheritance Attorney
Probate & Trusts
Trust • Experience • Results
Ready to Get Started?
Get started with Barnes Walker today.












